Throughout the whole book, I made many predictions of how it would end, however, the ending really caught me off guard. A little background information on the book is there is a girl named Libby and her two older sisters and mother were all brutally murdered in their home one night. The suspected murderer was her older brother Ben, and he had spent many years in prison due to everyone thinking he was guilty. I really enjoy how the author was able to make the ending something less predictable than normal mystery books. One of the plot twists that made the book’s ending less predictable is the fact that it wasn’t one murderer it was two. One of them was Diondra, Ben’s girlfriend, who killed Libby’s sister Michelle. Although I didn’t exactly think Diondra was a murderer it does make sense because she had a bit of temper and seemed pretty self-absorbed. Therefore if killing Michelle is what worked best for her, then I could see her doing it. The second murder is what surprised me the most. Libby’s mom Patty hired someone to come kill her. Patty wanted to do this to benefit her children which at first I couldn’t understand until she described how it would help them. The family had a lot of debt and Patty was attempting to make sure her children had enough to live off, and by dying they would get some money from her life insurance. Patty seemed like a pretty selfless person and I could tell that she genuinely cared about her children, I don’t think that leaving them motherless was the best way to go about it, although she was just trying to make their lives better. Libby’s other sister Debby wasn’t originally supposed to die, but unfortunately, she walked out of her room and saw the guy who killed her mom which resulted in her having to die as well.
I think a common theme that this book attempts to portray is that you can’t always blame the person who seems the easiest to blame. People took all of their previous opinions and thoughts of Ben and used that against him when the murders happened. Nobody really gave him a chance to redeem himself because everyone turned against him so fast. Ben spent so much of his life being treated unfairly due to people’s inability to do more research.